Fish Sauce substitutes
The best substitute for fish sauce is soy sauce + anchovy: Per 1 tbsp fish sauce: 1 tbsp soy sauce + 1 mashed anchovy fillet, warmed until it dissolves. Very close on the fermented-fish depth. Mash the anchovy completely or you get salty lumps. Use tamari if you need it gluten-free.
Why it matters. Fermented anchovy liquid that supplies salt and an intense savoury backbone to Thai and Vietnamese cooking. The smell is strong in the bottle but cooks away, leaving depth. Without it a pad thai or a dipping sauce tastes hollow.
BestSoy sauce + anchovy
●●●●○Per 1 tbsp fish sauce: 1 tbsp soy sauce + 1 mashed anchovy fillet, warmed until it dissolves
Keeps the umami, flavour and liquid roles.
Very close on the fermented-fish depth. Mash the anchovy completely or you get salty lumps. Use tamari if you need it gluten-free.
Vegan fish sauce
●●●●○1:1, then taste for salt
Keeps the umami, flavour and liquid roles.
Usually built from seaweed and dried mushroom. Convincingly briny and savoury but generally less salty, so adjust at the end.
Worcestershire sauce
●●●○○1:1, then taste and add salt
Keeps the umami, flavour and liquid roles.
Also anchovy-based, so it lands closer than plain soy, but it is sweeter, much more vinegary and considerably less salty.
Soy sauce + lime juice
●●●○○Per 1 tbsp: 2 tsp soy sauce + 1 tsp lime juice + a pinch of sugar
Keeps the umami, flavour and liquid roles.
Salty and bright, but with none of the fermented funk that makes a nuoc cham taste right. Best where fish sauce is a background note rather than the point.
Kombu and shiitake brine
●●●○○Simmer 1/2 cup water with 2 tbsp soy sauce, a 5cm piece of kombu and 3 dried shiitake for 15 min, then strain; use 1:1
Keeps the umami, flavour and liquid roles.
Genuinely savoury and vegan, but thinner and far less pungent, so a punchy dipping sauce ends up tasting tame.
Oyster sauce
●●●○○1:1, and cut the sugar in the recipe
Keeps the umami and flavour roles; loses liquid.
Thicker and sweeter, so it changes the body of a thin dipping sauce as well as the flavour. Better in a stir-fry than in a dressing.
Shrimp paste
●●●○○Per 1 tbsp: 1 tsp shrimp paste dissolved in 2 tsp water
Keeps the umami, flavour and liquid roles.
Far more intense and much funkier, and it has to be cooked to mellow. Never use it raw in a dressing.
Other sauce substitutes
Measuring by weight instead? Use the kitchen converter.